Andy Beyer's take on Big Brown et al and the Belmont

So usually I think Andy Beyer is a bit harsh, but he hits the nail right on the head about Big Brown’s people in this article in the Daily Racing Form earlier this week.  On top of the facts that the horse will likely never run again after today and this year’s crop has been, in my opinion, extremely mediocre therefore he has had essentially no competition on the TC trail, I hope someone in the field pulls a major upset.  And it won’t be Casino Drive :frowning:

drf.com/news/article/95176.html

[i]Lots of attention - not all of it good
By ANDREW BEYER

People in the racing business hope every year to see a Triple Crown winner who can stimulate the public’s and the media’s interest in the sport. Big Brown’s bid to make history has indeed attracted widespread attention, but it has often been attention that the industry doesn’t want, because the 2008 Triple Crown has sometimes shown racing at its worst. The series began with a filly, Eight Belles, dying on the track at Churchill Downs, and it is likely to end with the dismaying sight of owner Michael Iavarone and trainer Rick Dutrow celebrating in the winner’s circle at Belmont Park.

Horse racing has always attracted its share of rogues and charlatans, but few have been as brazen as Iavarone, co-CEO of the IEAH Stable. Iavarone presented himself as an investment banker who had made a fortune on Wall Street and was turning his business acumen to the horse racing game. The media lapped up his story, and even publications such as The New York Times and Business Week credulously reported that he had prospered on Wall Street.

Writer David Evans of Bloomberg.com exposed the lies: Iavarone had never been an investment banker. He was a stockbroker at firms peddling penny stocks; he was fined and suspended for securities offenses. When his career in the investment business fizzled, he turned to horse racing.

Iavarone’s sudden prominence in racing underscores the weakness of the sport’s regulatory system and should be a caution for any innocent who considers investing in horses. Iavarone couldn’t sell a share of a 10-cent gold-mining stock without being licensed by the securities industry and making his professional history a matter of public record. But he was soliciting investments for a $100 million horse-racing “hedge fund” without disclosing his background - a fact that has sparked disbelief and derision from commentators outside the sport. John Helyar, co-author of “Barbarians at the Gate,” wrote for Bloomberg.com: " ‘Big Brown’ has taken on a whole new meaning. It describes the . . . dung piles littering Iavarone’s past."

For his part, Iavarone acknowledged to Evans that in 2003 he “wasn’t in good financial shape.” He told The New York Times: “I’ve learned my lesson and moved on from that life, and I don’t know how the mistakes I made 15 years ago are relevant now.”

There are plenty of problems in Dutrow’s past, too, and since he has been in the public eye with Big Brown they have all been dug up again. The trainer’s record includes many drug-related infractions, most of them in cases where medications such as phenylbutazone and clenbuterol have registered over the legal limit in a horse’s system. In U.S. racing, this is considered business as usual; trainers regularly push the envelope and try to give their horses the maximum allowable dose of every drug that can help them.

Dutrow acknowledged that he administers the anabolic steroid Winstrol to Big Brown once a month, and before the Preakness he told reporters: “I don’t know what it does. I just like using it.” He was at least candid enough to talk about the use of steroids, which is one of the sport’s dirty little secrets. With no national regulatory organization, there is no uniformity in the banning of performance-enhancing substances.

But in the aftermath of Eight Belles’ death, when the sport has been heaped with criticism about the way racehorses are treated, Dutrow is an uncomfortable reminder that successful trainers use drugs - including ones like anabolic steroids that may do them harm.

Dutrow’s record lists many more serious infractions. He got a 60-day suspension in 2005 when two of his horses tested positive for Mepivacaine, a drug that deadens pain and might allow infirm horses to keep running hard, further injuring themselves. He was suspended for violating the terms of a suspension by maintaining contact with his assistants. He was fined for falsifying workouts of Wild Desert before the colt went to Canada and won the nation’s biggest race, the Queen’s Plate. (After the owner of the colt boasted that he had won $100,000 betting the horse, Canadian racing officials were seething.)

Yet even if Dutrow didn’t have a single blemish on his official record, rival trainers, track officials, and bettors would still view him with suspicion. After Dutrow acquires new horses, he seemingly has the power to transform them magically. When he took over the training of Saint Liam in 2003, the colt had won only two minor races in seven starts. Under Dutrow’s care he was a new horse, winning four Grade 1 stakes and the Horse of the Year title. When a trainer does this once, it’s a remarkable feat. But when he improves horses dramatically on a regular basis, he will be suspected of taking some unfair edge. Dutrow does it on a regular basis. Over the past five years, the horses he has claimed have won an astonishing 35 percent of the time in the first start for his barn.

In many other countries, trainers with Dutrow’s record and reputation would be booted out of the sport. In the U.S., where penalties for medication violations are usually laughable, an unsavory reputation is scarcely a handicap, because owners gravitate to high-percentage trainers. When the IEAH Stable’s previous trainer was socked with criminal charges for cheating with one of the stable’s horses, IEAH sought out Dutrow. And thus did he eventually get the opportunity to train Big Brown.

Even Dutrow’s severest detractors have to admit, however grudgingly, that he has distinguished himself since he has been in the public eye with Big Brown. He has been entertaining, candid, and disarmingly frank about his own past malfeasances. He has handled the colt with marvelous finesse, using an extraordinarily light regimen to get him ready for his powerful Preakness victory. He will deserve abundant credit if Big Brown captures the Triple Crown, just as Iavarone will deserve credit for being smart enough to buy the colt when he was a virtual unknown. But the only admirable figure in the Belmont winner’s circle will be Big Brown.

© 2008 The Washington Post[/i]

Ugh, I agree.  After all the years of wishing and wanting a TC winner, this year it looks like we finally have a chance and I’m rooting against the horse.  I didn’t like Smarty Jones that much, but I didn’t root against him.  I think part of it is I feel cheated b/c in my mind it “should” have gone to Barbaro, but the connections of Big Brown seem more like scum than the criminals who owned part of Curlin.  Even with them I liked Curlin!  Wish Casino Drive had made the race… Guess we’ll see what happens in a couple hours.

Haha, I felt sort of a hypocrite because I loved Curlin despite his connections (though his one owner, Jess Jackson is one of the good guys) and I just can’t get behind Big Brown because of his.

It does seem hard to root for him, but I’ve found myself more amenable to it lately, just because he seems to be having a good time running.  I absolutely don’t like his connections (partly because of the way they acted about the Eight Belles tragedy), but it seems he has a good chance.  I was going to pull for Casino Drive and the upset, but since he’s out, it’s gotta be Brown.  Bleh. 

ugh, im sure everyone else is watching… rick dutrow is such an a**. 

haha Dutrow can’t even face the cameras.

I do feel bad for BB and Kent D. but relieved that the first TC in 30 years didnt go to the likes of Dutrow and IEAH!

BB is the first triple crown hopeful to finish last in the Belmont.

I love how they are going crazy trying to think up an excuse for him. Maybe he isn’t as great as you thought he was Mr. Dutrow.

I just wanted the jockey to win cause of his son. But it’s pretty sweet that Da’tara led wire-wire esp with his young jockey who just won his 3rd GI race EVER!! :slight_smile:

aww, jockey is really cute - garcia - first belmont start, 20 years old or so, only his 3rd GI win or so… very cute :slight_smile:

Zito, man, you gotta watch out for this guy if you’re gunning for a TC sweep.

Can’t wait to see Dutrow in front of the camera with the wind knocked out of him

I would have to completely agree… I think BB is definitely a classy enough horse to have deserved it, as is Kent after his reformation… even though I did doubt that a Boundary son would go 10 furlongs ( Kent did say he had no horse left after the final turn)…  but, then again, what do you expect if you only breeze the horse over 5 furlongs…:-P… I am a devil, I know…
However, I do believe that Dutrow and IEAH are horrible people…  I love the reference Beyer makes to Ivarone not being able to sell 10-cent gold stocks without the SEC raising an eyebrow, but convincing millionaires to give him $100M’s to ‘invest’ in something as ‘sound’ as racehorses is a totally legit… WTF?  The regulations on hedge funds are soooooo obnoxiously loose it makes me sick… Nearly as sick as the notion that this is totally $$ to them…

Also, I wonder if anyone is going to question what effects Winstrol has?  LOL… I think it does a little bit more than anyone thought…

However, I am relieved in a bizarre way… We nearly had to deal with an awesome horse with a crappy name winning the TC in 2004 with Smarty Jones…  It would’ve killed me for anyone to reference BB and Secretariat, Citation or Affirmed in the same sentence. Those horses had champion names!

Dont pick on Smarty!  Loved that horse!  And being from Philly, its the closest thing we had to a sports championship in 25 years :slight_smile:  I blame Smarty’s loss on the jock.  Barbaro would have done it I think.  And Real Quiet was deserving too!  At least these guys ran against someone too.  Who has BB really beaten (aside from Eight Belles)?

I think this is the best possible outcome for the race, IMO.  Big Brown not only loses, but goes down in history as the first TC hopeful to finish last in the Belmont.  Awesome.  Assuming, of course, that BB lost b/c of the foot/steroids/heat, and not because his body’s shutting down internally or something seriously life-threatening.

Loved that Dutrow was being a jerk to the media…way to (not) eat crow there, “babe”.  (Obviously I don’t fault him for focusing on the horse, but it sounded like he was pretty rude to the journalists, which seems a bit much given how much smack he’s been talking for months.)

Go Da’Tara and Zito!  Zito is the TC Killer. :wink:

Well, I hope Big Brown isn’t seriously injured.  I imagine they’ll x-ray every inch of him but he looked like his normal self the little we could see of him walking in the shed row.  I imagine at that point the adrenaline has left him so he’d feel anything.

He never looked dull, just maybe a bit sluggish and totally non-responsive when asked to run.  I think he got upset about getting bumped around at the start, which Jerry Bailey said was no excuse for not running and that he might’ve been feeling the effects of no steroids.  I don’t think the foot was an issue unless it was just that he (BB) didn’t feel comfortable running on it because it still felt strange to him.

Now the question becomes… does IEAH have the guts to ever put him back on a track to redeem himself or do they retire him “because something’s obviously wrong that we just can’t find.”  I’d love to see Curlin beat him.

(Also, Curlin got assigned 128 for the Foster, so I can’t see them running him at that.  Of course, if you don’t want to get a massive weight assigned then don’t enter a Handicap!)

Can anyone point me to a listing of the full results for the race? I’d love to see where Guadalcanal placed. Hey, he DID beat Big Brown after all! :slight_smile:

I think any horse that can go wire-to-wire in the Belmont, no matter how mediocre the year’s crop, is a respectable racehorse. I was thrilled when I realized that Da’tara was going to do it.

Has anyone considered that, just maybe, it was 93 degrees out and Big Brown had never run that far before… maybe he just didn’t want to do it anymore?

11th Race

Belmont S. (G1)

Next Post 7:19  Off: 6:31 | 1 1/2 Miles | 3 Year Olds | Stakes | Purse: $1,000,000

Horse Jockey Weight Win Place Show

6 Da’ Tara Garcia Alan 126 79.00 28.00 14.80
4 Denis of Cork Albarado R J 126 5.40 4.10
8 DH-Anak Nakal Leparoux J R 126 7.60
9 DH-Ready’s Echo Velazquez J R 126 6.20

Finish Time: 2:29.65

Scratched: Casino Drive

Also ran: Macho Again, Tale of Ekati, Guadalcanal, Icabad Crane and Big Brown

Winning Trainer: Zito Nicholas P - Owner: LaPenta Robert V.

$2  Exacta  (6-4)  Paid $659.00

$2  Trifecta  (6-4-8)  Paid $3,703.00

$2  Trifecta  (6-4-9)  Paid $3,954.00

$2  Superfecta  (6-4-8-9)  Paid $48,637.00

$2  Superfecta  (6-4-9-8)  Paid $47,309.00

$2  Daily Double  (10-6)  Paid $1,574.00  Daily Double  Pool

$2  Daily Double  (BROOKLYN / BELMONT 2-6)  Paid $550.00  Daily Double  Pool

$2  Pick 3  (5-10-6)  3 Correct Paid $6,475.00  Pick 3  Pool

$2  Pick 4  (1-5-10-6)  4 Correct Paid $34,287.00  Pick 4  Pool

$2  Pick 6  (3/7-4-1-5-10-6)  5 Correct Paid $1,106.00  Pick 6  Pool

$2  Consolation Double  (BROOKLYN / BELMONT 2-5)  Paid $7.30

Yup :slight_smile:  I seriously hope that theres not a hair out of place on the horse, not only for BB’s sake (which is first and foremost), but to see Dutrow and IEAH try to save face.  The heat, the distance, not handling the track, “bouncing” (they called the Preakness his bounce, but his numbers were just low because Kent slowed him down), his breeding, being tired from the TC trail, bad karma from his connections, distracted, getting jostled going into the first turn and having to deal with that for one of the first times…

I think theyll wimp out and go ahead and retire him, regardless.  God forbid they lose a race again.  I would love to see a Curlin-BB race, though.  Would also love to see Curlin go up against Einstein in the Foster, but I dont blame em for shying away from 128, thats quite a lot when youre spotting other GI winners up to 10 lbs.

PS - realized im about every other post on this thread hehe :slight_smile:  Im out of town by myself with no cable (had to go buy an antenna for the tv to watch the race!), no one to talk to, and my laptop, so you guys are my post race discussion/venting :wink:

Thanks!

And sorry if my first post sounded catty…I really do like Big Brown, and did pull for him in the Derby, but the more I learned about the people who handle him the less enthused I got about the Triple Crown. (And the more I learned about his feet, the more disgusted I got at the thought of them running out and breeding him…or is that a super-common thing for horses? Please enlighten me there.)

I’m glad that Desormeaux pulled him up when he felt that things weren’t going well. I like him and this is further proof that he’s a class act IMHO.

Asmussun freaked out about it. Someone needs to remind him that 128lbs for a handicap is a joke.

Didn’t Seabiscut run (and win) under 130+? Thought and in his narrow loss in the Santa Anita Handicap to Stagehand he gave as much as 30lbs to some horses in the race. So I mean its not like horses have never soundly carried that kind of weight before.

I think Asmussen should run him, cause if he wins under that weight it would prove just how good he is!!